Insight

A(nother) Turning Point for Intra-EU ECT Disputes?

Client Alerts

Two ICSID tribunals have recently upheld Spain’s intra-European Union (EU) jurisdictional objections in two arbitrations pursuant to the Energy Charter Treaty (“ECT”).1

Both cases arise out of Spain’s decision to modify its incentives scheme for renewable energy investments in 2013/2014, under which the prior scheme was abolished in favour of a system of incentives based on a reasonable rate of return calculated by reference to market remuneration. The claims were commenced against Spain in 2018 and 2019 respectively under the ECT.

While the awards currently remain unpublished, it has been reported that both Tribunals found by majority that they did not have jurisdiction over the disputes, as they determined that the competence of the matters in dispute to have been transferred to the EU. In a 14 October 2024 press release, Spain confirmed that: “the Energy Charter Treaty has the meaning advocated by Spain and the European Commission, according to which the participation of the EU in the ECT, as a regional economic interest organisation, introduced into its scope the supremacy of EU law in the area of competences transferred by the member states to the EU.”2

Spain’s jurisdictional objection, commonly referred to as the ‘intra-EU’ objection, follows the well-known Achmea (2018) and Komstroy (2021) decisions by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), in which it was ruled that intra-EU treaty claims (including ECT disputes) between EU investors and states were not compliant with EU law, as they interfered with the autonomy and application of EU law and were incompatible with Articles 267 and 344 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union.

However, this is the first time that an ICSID tribunal has reached this decision. Up until now, while a significant number of ICSID tribunals have faced this question, all have continued to maintain their jurisdiction over these type of disputes, primarily on the basis that they derive their legitimacy from an international treaty and are therefore subject to public international law, and not EU law.

The only other tribunal that had previously upheld an intra-EU objection was Green Power v. Spain. However, given this was a Stockholm Chamber of Commerce (SCC) arbitration, seated in Sweden, the interpretation of the arbitration agreement had been subject to Swedish, and therefore EU, law.

This recent change in approach by the ICSID tribunals also follows the recent decisions by both the EU and the United Kingdom to withdraw from the ECT, albeit subject to the 20-year sunset clause (which we have previously written about here and here), leaving the future of ECT disputes somewhat uncertain.

These novel rulings could therefore have wide-reaching implications for other investors both with pending, or potential, intra-EU arbitrations. This stark departure from the decisions reached by previous ICSID tribunals raises questions over whether there will now be a turn in the tide in ICSID tribunals declining jurisdiction over intra-EU energy disputes.

1 Sapec, S.A. v. Spain (ICSID Case No. ARB/19/23) and European Solar Farms v. Spain (ICSID Case No. ARB/18/45).

2 Spain’s Press Release.


This information is provided by Vinson & Elkins LLP for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended, nor should it be construed, as legal advice.

Discover our latest:

Insights

Events

Kathy Pakenham Speaking at ABA’s 2026 Criminal Tax Fraud and Tax Controversy Conference

Partner Kathy Pakenham will speak at the American Bar Association’s (ABA) 2026 Criminal Tax Fraud and Tax Controversy Conference on …

December 11, 2026

December 11, 2026 • 1-minute read

Events

Paige Anderson and Vinay Prabhakar to Present on BARBRI Webinar on REIT Tax and Data Centers

Partners Paige Anderson and Vinay Prabhakar will present on BARBRI’s live video CLE program, “Formation and Operation of Data Center …

December 10, 2026

December 10, 2026 • 1-minute read

CLE Events

Texas Data Centers in a New Political Landscape: Post-Midterm Outlook

The 2026 midterm elections are changing the policy landscape for data center development in Texas.

December 3, 2026

December 3, 2026 • 1-minute read

Events

Jenny Speck to Speak on BARBRI Webinar

Partner Jenny Speck will speak on BARBRI’s live video CLE program, “Tax Credit Insurance for Energy Projects: PFE Exclusions, Recapture, …

November 19, 2026

November 19, 2026 • 1-minute read

Events

Kathy Pakenham and Adriana Wirtz to Speak at TEI’s IRS Roundtable

Partners Kathy Pakenham and Adriana Wirtz will examine how a leaner, more data-driven IRS is selecting and conducting large business …

November 19, 2026

November 19, 2026 • 1-minute read

News & Achievements
V&E

Get in Touch

Thoughts or questions? Send us a note, and we’ll connect you with the right person.

The ESG GC: How Your Role as Chief Legal Officer is Integral To Your Company’s ESG Efforts Background Image