Events
Jenny Speck to Speak on BARBRI Webinar
Partner Jenny Speck will speak on BARBRI’s live video CLE program, “Tax Credit Insurance for Energy Projects: PFE Exclusions, Recapture, …
November 19, 2026
November 19, 2026 • 1-minute read
Insight
Client Alerts
V&E IP Update
April 5, 2023 • 3-minute read
On April 3, 2023, in Ironburg Inventions Ltd. v. Valve Corp., Nos. 21-2296, 21-2297, 22-1070 (Fed. Cir. Apr. 3, 2023), the Federal Circuit for the first time defined the standard for determining the scope of estoppel set forth in 35 U.S.C. § 315(e)(2) for prior art that was not raised in an inter partes review (“IPR”) petition. Under Section 315(e)(2), the petitioner for an IPR that reaches a final written decision may not assert invalidity in a district court or at the International Trade Commission based on “any ground that the petitioner raised or reasonably could have raised” in the IPR. The Federal Circuit held that grounds the petitioner “reasonably could have raised” are “invalidity grounds a skilled searcher conducting a diligent search reasonably could have been expected to discover.” Further, the court held that it is the patent owner who bears the burden of establishing in the district court that the estoppel applies.
In Ironburg, the plaintiff moved for a pre-trial order pursuant to Section 315(e)(2) to preclude the defendant — who had prevailed in having some, but not all of the asserted claims cancelled in its own IPR — from asserting two additional invalidity grounds that it later discovered through a third party’s IPR petition. Those grounds included three prior art references that were not identified in defendant’s own prior art searching. The district court granted the plaintiff’s motion to preclude reliance on those grounds, which effectively removed invalidity as an issue at trial.
On appeal, the Federal Circuit vacated and remanded that portion of the district court’s order “[b]ecause the district court improperly placed the burden of proof on Valve [Corp.], to show that it could not ‘reasonably . . . have raised’ the Non-Petitioned Grounds in its petition.” As a threshold (and uncontested) issue, the Federal Circuit adopted a standard equating grounds that reasonably could have been raised with “grounds a skilled searcher conducting a diligent search reasonably could have been expected to discover.” The Federal Circuit then held that, consistent with other affirmative defenses, “the burden of proving, by a preponderance of the evidence, that a skilled searcher exercising reasonable diligence would have identified an invalidity ground rests on the patent holder, as the party asserting and seeking to benefit from the affirmative defense of IPR estoppel.”
In this case, the plaintiff had not produced any evidence related to the “reasonableness” of the third party’s search, which left a “hole in the record” that was not defendant’s obligation to fill. The Federal Circuit noted that had the third party’s search involved “extraordinary measures” or “‘scorched earth’ tactics,” they would have gone beyond “reasonable diligence.” The Federal Circuit also brushed aside other concerns raised by the plaintiff about search efforts being protected by attorney-client privilege because (1) “privilege issues” are commonplace in patent cases and resolving such issues can factor into a court’s decision to grant estoppel, and (2) the relevant inquiry focuses on what a skilled searcher “would find through reasonable diligence and not what an actual researcher in fact did find through whatever level of diligence she exercised.”
Although the Federal Circuit’s Ironburg decision places the burden on patent owners to demonstrate that Section 315(e)(2) applies to estop a defendant from asserting certain invalidity grounds, patent owners will likely have a hindsight advantage to show that a particular prior art reference could have been discovered by a skilled searcher exercising reasonable diligence. Skilled patent attorneys are likely to have little difficulty connecting the dots back from nearly any English-language patent or printed publication to a challenged patent. Global search databases and machine-translation capabilities will likely bring even more obscure references into the ambit of the skilled searcher. The quintessential foreign-language article, shelved in the recesses of a German library, may present a bit more of a challenge. On the other side, defendants seeking to avoid IPR estoppel of later-discovered prior art references will likely need to divulge at least some details related to their own prior art searching to demonstrate a search was performed with reasonable diligence without uncovering the new reference. Given that the Federal Circuit left the door open for the lower court to reopen discovery on this issue, in the future, parties may also seek third-party discovery of another’s prior art search efforts that uncovered relevant prior art.
This information is provided by Vinson & Elkins LLP for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended, nor should it be construed, as legal advice.
Discover our latest:
Events
Jenny Speck to Speak on BARBRI Webinar
Partner Jenny Speck will speak on BARBRI’s live video CLE program, “Tax Credit Insurance for Energy Projects: PFE Exclusions, Recapture, …
November 19, 2026
November 19, 2026 • 1-minute read
Events
Kathy Pakenham and Adriana Wirtz to Speak at TEI’s IRS Roundtable
Partners Kathy Pakenham and Adriana Wirtz will examine how a leaner, more data-driven IRS is selecting and conducting large business …
November 19, 2026
November 19, 2026 • 1-minute read
Articles
Retrofitting Carbon Capture on Energy-from-Waste: Making the Systems Connect
Carbon capture can turn the energy-from-waste fleet into a source of carbon removals. Experience of EfW projects shows how well-drafted …
November 18, 2026
November 18, 2026 • 6-minute read
Client Alerts
The SEC Proposes to Rein In Executive Compensation Disclosure
On November 13, 2026, the SEC proposed an overhaul of the executive and director compensation disclosure rules in Item 402 …
November 17, 2026
November 17, 2026 • 10-minute read
Client Alerts
Single v Multi Contracts in Nuclear Projects: The Size of the Burden
Introduction The construction of nuclear energy projects is complex and capital-intensive, and the contracting structure can significantly affect project delivery, …
November 13, 2026
November 13, 2026 • 6-minute read
Deals & Cases
Vinson & Elkins Represents Double Eagle in Sale of Midland Basin Assets to Diamondback Energy
Vinson & Elkins represented Double Eagle IV Midco, LLC and Double Eagle V Midco, LLC (together “Double Eagle”) in entering …
November 16, 2026
November 16, 2026 • 1-minute read
Media Coverage
Vinson & Elkins Partner Joyce Adetutu joined CorpGov on the inaugural episode of Beyond the Boardroom, a new series co-produced …
November 9, 2026
November 9, 2026 • 1-minute read
Deals & Cases
Vinson & Elkins Advises Underwriters on Enterprise Products’ $1.5 Billion Senior Notes Offering
Vinson and Elkins advised the underwriters in connection with Enterprise Products Operating LLC’s (“EPO”) public offering of $1.5 billion aggregate …
November 6, 2026
November 6, 2026 • 1-minute read
Media Coverage
Aubrey Bishai Explains Responsible Vibe Coding and AI Innovation in Law.com
Vinson & Elkins Chief Innovation Officer Aubrey Bishai was featured in Law.com’s coverage of LegalTech Connect’s 2026 Knowledge Management & …
November 5, 2026
November 5, 2026 • 1-minute read
Deals & Cases
Vinson & Elkins Advises Southern Realty Trust Inc. in Merger with Sunrise Realty Trust, Inc.
Vinson & Elkins advised Southern Realty Trust Inc. in connection with its entry into a definitive merger agreement with Sunrise …
November 5, 2026
November 5, 2026 • 1-minute read
Articles
Innovation and Investment: The Next Frontier in Aerospace and Defense
Vinson & Elkins Partners Sebastian Tiller and Ben Heriaud sit down for a conversation on the firm’s Aerospace and Defense …
November 3, 2026
November 3, 2026 • 6-minute read
Articles
Law Is a Practice. So Is Business Development.
Randi Revisore, Lauren Alford, and DeAnna Englezos reflect on two years of success leading BD Lab — Vinson & Elkins’ …
July 14, 2026 • V&E+ | Values
July 14, 2026 • 7-minute read
Articles
Data Center Dealmakers: A New Era of Power and Compute
Vinson & Elkins Partners Creighton Smith and Milam Newby share the story behind a groundbreaking AI infrastructure transaction — and …
June 15, 2026 • V&E+ Ventures
June 15, 2026 • 5-minute read
Client Alerts
Mid-Level Mindset: Empowering Lawyers Through a Pivotal Career Stage
Vinson & Elkins’ inaugural Mid-Level Associate Summit brought lawyers from across the firm to Houston for three days of learning …
March 31, 2026
March 31, 2026 • 5-minute read
Client Alerts
Pro Bono at Vinson & Elkins: Lawyers Changing Lives
Pro Bono Counsel Parker Cragg reflects on a life dedicated to service, returning to Vinson & Elkins, and wisdom he has picked up along the way.
October 20, 2025 • V&E+ Values
October 20, 2025 • 6-minute read
Thoughts or questions? Send us a note, and we’ll connect you with the right person.
our People
Please note that any communication with Vinson & Elkins via e-mail through this website does not constitute or create an attorney-client relationship with V&E. Please do not send any confidential information. A conflicts-of-interest procedure must be completed by V&E prior to establishment of an attorney-client relationship. When you execute an engagement letter from V&E you will be our client, and you may then exchange information freely with a V&E attorney.
By clicking “Accept,” you agree that we may review any information you transmit to us. You recognize that our review of your information, even if it is highly confidential and even if it is transmitted in a good faith effort to retain us, does not preclude us from representing another client directly adverse to you, even in a matter where that information could and will be used against you.