X

Reset Password

Username:

Change Password

Old Password:
New Password:
We have completed your request.

False Claims Act Statistics, News & Analysis

Escobar Matters for Discovery, Too: District Court Emphasizes Right to Broad Materiality Discovery

While most post-Escobar decisions have involved the merits, Escobar also has significant implications for the scope of materiality discovery under the FCA. Last week, in United States ex rel. California v. Paramedics Plus LLC, the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas became one of the first courts to directly tackle that issue in a written opinion, holding that Escobar affords FCA defendants the ability to broadly discover how the government has actually handled the disputed issue, both in that case and in other analogous situations.

Read More

Holding a Mere Temporal Link Between Kickbacks and Medicare Claims Is Too Weak — the Third Circuit Says Goodbye to Relator's Case

Consistent with other recent decisions we have blogged about, the Third Circuit recently held in United States ex rel. Greenfield v. Medco Health Solutions, Inc., that to survive summary judgment, a relator must link alleged kickbacks to specific claims for payment submitted to the government; it is not enough to merely allege that the “taint” of a kickback scheme renders false every claim submitted while that scheme is ongoing. Finding no such link between the defendants’ Medicare claims and an alleged kickback scheme, the Third Circuit affirmed summary judgment for the defendants.

Read More
  • 24
  • January
  • 2018

Author:

Share on:

"Taint" Theory of Damages Dead in the Seventh Circuit? One District Court Has Not Received the Message

Adopting a view that has been roundly rejected by federal circuit courts (including the Seventh Circuit), the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois in United States & City of Chicago ex rel. Chicago Regional Council of Carpenters v. Sound Solutions Windows & Doors, Inc. endorsed the “taint” theory of FCA damages, awarding the full value of contracts as damages based on the defendants’ non-compliance with a contractual term, notwithstanding their complete performance of the tangible work under the contracts.

Read More
  • 31
  • October
  • 2017

Author:

Share on:

Escobar Continues to Bring More Treats Than Tricks For FCA Defendants — Seventh Circuit Overrules Longstanding Causation Precedent, Adopts Proximate Cause Standard

Handing out a pre-Halloween treat to FCA defendants, the Seventh Circuit last week overruled its 1992 decision adopting a “but-for” causation standard to join its sister circuits in holding that FCA plaintiffs must prove that a defendant’s false claim was both the but-for and proximate (i.e., foreseeable) cause of the government’s loss.

Read More
  • 19
  • October
  • 2017

Author:

Share on:

Not a Bullseye, But the Government Hits Its Mark, Settling Triple Canopy for $2.6 Million

Earlier this week, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of Virginia announced that defense contractor Triple Canopy has agreed to settle the long-running FCA suit related to its provision of security services in Iraq. Although a victory for the government, contractors can take some comfort from the fact that the $2.6 million settlement represents less than 25 percent of the damages sought in the government’s complaint-in-intervention (which totaled more than $12 million when trebled). $500,000 of the settlement will be paid to the relator pursuant to the FCA’s qui tam provisions.

Read More

A Year after U.S. ex rel. Escobar, Lower Courts Diverge on Key Question in Implied-False-Certification FCA Suits

Just over a year ago, False Claims Act (FCA) watchers eagerly awaited the US Supreme Court’s decision in U.S. ex rel. Escobar v. Universal Health Services, Inc., expecting that it would resolve once and for all whether implied false certification is a valid FCA theory. V&E’s Craig Margolis and Christian Sheehan provide a post-Escobar analysis in an article they recently wrote for Washington Legal Foundation (WLF).

Read More

Filter By

Sign Up for Updates

Receive email news and alerts about False Claims Act/Qui Tam Litigation from V&E

Dates

Follow Us On Linkedin